Key Takeaways
- Retirement plan sponsors must complete annual nondiscrimination and compliance testing to verify contribution limits, employee coverage and adherence to Internal Revenue Service (IRS) requirements.
- Failed retirement plan compliance tests require timely corrective action to avoid excise taxes, protect tax-qualified status and address potential financial statement implications.
- For calendar-year plans, corrective distributions for failed nondiscrimination tests are generally due March 15, with a June 30 deadline for qualifying automatic contribution arrangements.
As the 2026 plan year audit season approaches, it is important for plan sponsors to remember their responsibility for conducting required nondiscrimination and other compliance tests relating to a retirement plan in a timely manner. Nondiscrimination testing helps prevent a plan from disproportionately benefiting highly compensated employees. The tests applicable to a plan vary based on the type of plan [e.g., defined contribution − 401(k), 403(b) or defined benefit] and several other factors.
Testing Parameters
Certain safe-harbor contribution formulas may satisfy specific nondiscrimination requirements without additional testing, but other testing requirements may still apply. A plan may also qualify for other exceptions to the nondiscrimination testing if an exception is provided in the Internal Revenue Code.
Other compliance testing (e.g., ensuring dollar limits of contributions made by the participant, employer or on a combined basis) are required to be performed on an annual basis.
Other required testing includes a coverage test (i.e., ensuring the number of participants benefiting satisfies the requirements) and, where applicable, a top-heavy test.
The performance of these various tests is often performed by the record keeper of the plan or outsourced to a third-party administrator, accounting firm or other professional organization who needs access to the plan’s records and the knowledge to properly perform these tests.
Failure of any of these tests requires the plan administrator to take timely corrective action(s), which could include making additional contributions to the plan, notifying participants of the matter, additional reporting or possibly submitting an application under the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Voluntary Correction Program, depending on the failure and available correction options.
Auditor’s Responsibilities
Auditors review the compliance testing applicable to a plan to verify the implications, if any, on the plan’s financial statements. An auditor’s responsibilities include reviewing the plan’s tax status, determining whether management has performed and complied with the applicable tests and whether failures, if any, were corrected in a proper manner.
Auditors will also review the financial statement disclosures regarding the plan’s tax status to determine if any additional disclosures are warranted. Although auditors perform the following as it relates to the plan’s compliance testing, plan sponsors remain responsible for ensuring required testing is completed and any failures are corrected timely.
Failure to comply with these testing requirements could jeopardize a plan’s tax status, which would have an effect on participants, the employer and the plan’s trust. Safe harbor plans are not exempt from every qualification requirement. Timely completion of the tests protects the participants, the employer and produces a timelier audit.
Timing
For a December 31st plan year-end, corrective distributions for failed actual deferral percentage (ADP)/actual contribution percentage (ACP) should generally be made by March 15th of the following year to avoid a 10% excise tax. For corrections made after March 15th or before December 31st of the year following the plan year being tested, any corrective refunds trigger a 10% excise tax on applicable excess contributions to be paid by the employer to the IRS with the filing of the Form 5330.
Plans with qualifying eligible automatic contribution arrangements (EACAs) generally have until June 30th of the following year to make corrective distributions without triggering the excise tax. For corrections made after December 31st of the subsequent plan year, the failure becomes a qualification issue requiring correction under the IRS Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System (EPCRS). EPCRS is the IRS system for correcting failures, which is necessary to address the qualification failure and preserve a plan’s tax-qualified status.
For plans that consistently fail testing, employers may want to review their plan design to determine if changes are warranted to reduce the failures. For the reasons provided above, it would be beneficial for plans to have their testing completed as soon as administratively possible after the plan’s year end and before the audit commences.
We Can Assist
PKF O’Connor Davies Employee Benefit Plan Services team can help you understand your plan’s testing requirements, evaluate testing results and correction options and assess whether plan design changes can reduce recurring failures.
Contact Us
Contact your client engagement team or any of the partners listed below to discuss your plan’s compliance needs and how timely coordination with your service providers can support a smoother audit.
Louis F. LiBrandi, EA, CEBS, ChFC, TGPC, CPSP
Partner
llibrandi@pkfod.com | 646.449.6327
Matthew J. Corona, CPA
Partner
mcorona@pkfod.com | 914.341.7032

