Key Takeaways
-
Human resources (HR) operating models must evolve with business growth to address payroll complexity, compliance risks, recruitment demands and employee experience.
-
HR outsourcing and co-sourcing provide specialized expertise, operational continuity and scalable support while allowing leadership to retain strategic control.
-
An effective HR operating framework establishes clear accountability, documented processes, risk controls and ongoing performance reviews to strengthen efficiency and compliance.
In our previous article, “The CFO-CHRO Alliance: Building the Workforce at Every Inflection Point,” we discussed three business transitions that can prompt a workforce redesign and offered a repeatable framework that can help you continually optimize that workforce. In this article, we turn to the HR operating model and ask whether it can support that workforce.
Out of Step: When HR Becomes Misaligned with the Business
HR holds responsibility for complex, essential functions that are critical to the business, from managing payroll and employee benefits to recruiting top talent and maintaining compliance. As businesses grow and evolve, leaders may realize that their HR function no longer completely aligns with the needs of the business. Handling every HR function in-house can become too costly, time-consuming or inefficient.
These realities usually surface in day-to-day operations before they become strategic problems for leaders to solve. The scenarios below are where leaders first see the mismatch between the HR function they have and the HR function the business now needs:
- Managing payroll in-house can be time-consuming and risky. Mistakes can create compliance issues, costly fines and frustrated employees. Payroll does not wait if a key person is unavailable.
- Benefits questions about matters like health insurance, retirement plans, wellness programs, enrollment and eligibility and employee education can overtake the bandwidth of internal teams. Then they consume leadership time and affect employee engagement and retention.
- Recruiting the right talent during rapid growth or specialized hiring can overwhelm the team just when speed and candidate experience matter most.
- Employment laws keep changing. Staying compliant is non-negotiable. Yet company policies sometimes don’t keep up with changing regulations, creating compliance and risk exposure.
- Employee relations issues are handled inconsistently. Performance issues, grievances and terminations require legal knowledge, empathy and a standard approach across managers and offices.
- HR technology becomes outdated quickly. Training and development can fail to stay current with the business, but building programs internally is often too much of a resource drain.
None of these issues alone usually sparks a crisis. But when they start happening together, they reveal an operating model that can’t effectively support the business.
Where to Start in Solving HR Challenges?
If you’re a leader who recognizes some of these issues occurring in your own business, how do you resolve them? One answer is outsourcing. Some executives express concern about taking this route, believing that outsourcing HR services means giving up control. With the right approach, outsourcing can help leaders build a smarter, more efficient human resources strategy in partnership with experienced external professionals.
The HR Operating Model Decision Map
For a middle-market leadership team, the decision should start with the work itself. That way, you approach outsourcing as an operating model decision, not a cost-cutting measure. Instead of just taking work out of the business, you work toward making the function more scalable, more consistent and more supportable as the business grows.
Decision Zone | Where it Fits |
Keep close to leadership | Strategy, culture, leadership judgment, sensitive employee matters and decisions that define the employee experience. |
Build internally | Recurring work where volume, complexity and strategic importance justify dedicated internal capacity. |
Outsource | Specialized, rules-based or administration-heavy work where expertise, continuity and scale reduce risk. |
Co-source | Work that requires both internal context and outside execution capacity, especially during growth, transition or a major project. Leaders maintain strategic direction while gaining capacity. |
Benefits of Outsourcing Across HR Areas
Outsourcing provides several important benefits within HR. It lifts administrative burdens, protects against risk, improves the employee experience and gives internal teams more capacity to focus on business goals. Not to mention it gives you access to the strategic expertise needed to move the function and, therefore the business, forward. Let’s look in a little more depth at the pressure points we identified earlier and how outsourcing can make a difference.
Pressure Point | The Value of Outsourcing: A Stronger HR Model |
Payroll management | Working with an external partner supports accurate, on-time payroll, tax withholding, filing, year-end reporting and payroll continuity. |
Benefits administration | Outsourcing gives employees a better benefits experience without creating an unnecessary administrative burden. |
Recruitment and staffing | Recruitment process outsourcing can support sourcing, screening, coordination, employer branding and onboarding. This ultimately strengthens employee engagement and retention. |
Compliance and risk management | Policies, handbooks, safety audits, regulatory filings, harassment prevention and training need to remain current and defensible. Outsourcing helps ensure all of these matters stay up to date within the business. |
Employee relations support | Outside support can bring expertise and objectivity to investigations, conflict mediation, disciplinary actions and termination processes. |
Training and development | Keeping employee training and development current requires specialized support. Outsourcing is often chosen for leadership development, compliance training, skills-based learning and the implementation of learning management systems. |
HR technology solutions | Outsourcing can provide the implementation and integration expertise to produce efficient, data-driven and future-ready HR systems and processes. Updates and troubleshooting can be taken care of on an ongoing basis. |
What a Better HR Operating Model Looks Like
As the complexity of HR keeps rising, leaders need confidence that the HR operating model is clear, controlled and scalable. This is reflected in:
- Clear ownership across HR roles and responsibilities
- Documented processes and escalation paths
- Dependable data for decisions relating to payroll, benefits, compliance and the overall workforce
- A consistent employee experience across locations and managers
- Up-to-date company training, handbooks and policies
- An established routine for reviewing cost, risk, quality and business fit
Five Building Blocks of an Effective HR Operating Framework
As we have worked with HR leaders, we have developed a series of steps to strengthen HR operations, with questions leaders can ask at each step.
Building Block | Executive Question |
1. Define the HR operating model | Which HR responsibilities are strategic, administrative, compliance-sensitive or expertise-dependent? |
2. Clarify ownership and decision-making rights | Who owns the decision, who executes the process and who reviews the outcome? |
3. Build continuity into critical functions | Where is the business exposed to single-point-of-failure risk? |
4. Document the process and escalation path | Can managers, employees and leaders understand how issues are handled? |
5. Review performance over time | Are cost, risk, service quality, compliance and employee experience improving? |
Looking Ahead
As with any business function, the strongest HR operating models do not depend solely on expanding internal capacity or outsourcing. Leaders understand what is needed in changing environments and look for the best solution for the business. The most successful HR functions are built around several factors: the work required, the risks that must be controlled, the employee experience desired by leadership and the operational velocity needed to stay competitive.
It’s clear that when the model is designed with these factors in mind, HR outsourcing services can deliver strategic advantage by providing specialized expertise, advanced technologies and scalable support. Another key benefit is that it gives leaders more availability to focus on core business priorities. The result is not less control over HR. It’s a more disciplined way to keep the workforce running smoothly as the business evolves over time.
Contact Us
If you have any questions or would like to explore outsourced CFO and/or CHRO capabilities, please contact your PKF O’Connor Davies client service team or the article authors:
Roman Z. Matatov, CPA, MBA, FPAC, FMVA, CGMA, CITP, CVA, CFE, CFF
Partner
PKF O’Connor Davies
rmatatov@pkfod.com | 240.534.2797
Chris Timol
President
PuzzleHR
timol@puzzlehr.com | 610.301.2999
Next: “Navigating the Impact of AI on the Workforce.” A stronger HR operating model gives the organization a stronger platform for transformation. The next question is how the CHRO leads change – especially with AI – in a way that redesigns work, build trust and produces measurable progress.

