Key Takeaways
-
Private clubs should apply consistent capitalization policies based on asset cost, useful life and expenditure purpose to ensure accurate accounting and financial reporting.
-
Under generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), capital budget expenditures do not automatically qualify for capitalization. Routine maintenance generally must be expensed.
-
Accurate fixed asset records, annual reviews and proper disposal tracking help private clubs maintain financial transparency, strengthen internal controls and support compliance.
Property and equipment investments are critical to a private club’s operations and its member experience. A new irrigation system, bunker renovations or routine maintenance: Which expenses should the club capitalize and which should it expense? The answers aren’t always straightforward.
As part of managing these investments, many clubs have a capitalization policy in their accounting handbook that goes something like this: Equipment, furniture and fixtures, including software, whose value exceeds $2,000 must be capitalized. To qualify for capitalization, an asset must both meet the dollar amount threshold and have an estimated minimum useful life of five years.
Applying Your Capitalization Policy
But having a policy in place is only the starting point. Club management must apply it consistently, maintain accurate fixed asset records and review the policy occasionally to ensure it is still practical. Even with clearly defined policies, questions can arise about certain accounting treatments. When in doubt, clubs should remember that the nature and purpose of an expenditure determine its accounting treatment. Addressing these questions during the budgeting process, rather than at year-end, can help avoid unexpected adjustments and provide management and the club’s board with more reliable financial information.
To help clubs understand correct accounting treatment, we offer some general guidance for common situations:
Expenditure | Typical accounting treatment |
New irrigation system | Generally, capitalize |
Major bunker reconstruction | Generally, capitalize if it creates or substantially improves a long-lived asset |
Routine bunker maintenance | Expense |
New golf cart storage barn | Capitalize |
Architectural and engineering fees | Capitalize when directly attributable to qualifying construction |
Construction-related permits | Generally, capitalize |
Routine landscaping and tree maintenance | Expense |
Replacement of existing assets | Capitalize qualifying new assets and evaluate disposal of old assets |
Replacement of clubhouse carpeting | Generally, capitalize if it represents a qualifying improvement or separately identifiable asset, otherwise expense |
Routine painting of clubhouse | Generally, expense, unless directly attributable to a qualifying capital improvement project |
Why Capital Budget Items Aren’t Always Capitalized
Club management often believes that an expenditure included in the capital budget automatically should be capitalized using generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). This is a common misconception. While a club may designate funds for a particular project within its capital budget, the actual accounting treatment depends on the nature of the expenditure. For example, a club may budget $5 million of capital funds for its golf course, including a new irrigation system, bunker renovations and routine course maintenance. Although all three expenditures may be included in the capital budget, they may not all qualify for capitalization. As noted above, routine maintenance generally should be expensed. Other expenditures, such as the new irrigation system and bunker renovations, may qualify for capitalization if they create new assets, extend the useful lives of existing assets or substantially improve them.
Club management is often concerned that expensing a capital budget item can make it look like a department has exceeded its operating budget. One way to address this is to create individual expense accounts for each department to capture capital budget expenditures that don’t qualify for capitalization. Management can present these accounts separately for internal budget analysis while still reporting them as expenses under GAAP.
Maintaining Fixed Asset Records
Finally, it is important to implement and maintain certain best practices regarding the accounting and recordkeeping of fixed assets. Those records should include the corresponding invoice, purchase order and approval. We recommend that club management (e.g., chef, superintendent, etc.) review the fixed asset listing at least annually to ensure its accuracy as well as the correct recording of disposals/sales.
Contact Us
We welcome the opportunity to answer any questions you may have related to this topic or any other accounting, audit, tax or advisory matters for private and taxable clubs. Please reach out to your PKF O’Connor Davies client service team or:
Kerri Rawcliffe, CPA
Partner, Private Club Practice Leader
krawcliffe@pkfod.com
Steve Noyes, CPA
Partner
snoyes@pkfod.com
Brooke Rossi, CPA
Partner
brossi@pkfod.com
Amber Stone, CPA
Director
astone@pkfod.com

